OG_Clash detection vs quality control.jpg

Clash detection vs quality control: the differences

April 10, 2018 3 min. read

Let’s get straight to the point: clash detection is a subset of quality control. Quality control enhances the quality and the constructability of the model. And we’d like to demystify some of this quality control voodoo for you.

You could just share a QA/QC checklist it would be fine
We’d love to if we could, but it’s different for every project. The good news? You already have it. If you have a list of deliverables, this is  your quality assurance / quality control (QA/QC) checklist. All rules around the deliverables should be clearly defined so there is something to test against.

While it’s impossible to be exhaustive because ☝️, quality control generally includes :

Verifying if LOMD (LOD & LOI) & other deliverables are correct

LOD still can mean different things to different people. PhD candidate Marzia Bolpagni clarified the global definitions of LOD. This oldie but a goodie from Anthony McPhee, further defines LOD in very clear language.

Regardless, the parameters of your project’s LOMD should be clearly defined in the project deliverables. That’s right, it always comes back to the deliverables.

You will want to visually inspect your federated model to make sure that the LOMD is respected. Who should do it? A balance of the BIM production team & team members with strong construction experience.

Other things to look out for adherence to include:

  • Building codes
  • Standards
  • Overall & specific dimensions
  • All other project deliverable specifications.

Verifying model quality

You’ll also want to make sure the model is "clean". What do we mean? For example: no doubles of elements, elements in the wrong spot, filters and phases are correct, model size is reasonable, etc.

It’s better to fix these things particularly before running clash detection (yes, we’re getting to that shortly!)  or you will be increasing your issues exponentially.

A note before we move onto clash detection

finger tip

Quality control should be a regular process, from design through to construction. You should never be in the unfortunate position of only doing QC right before a deadline. If the verifications outlined above are not performed, your clash detection could be utterly pointless if performed on inaccurate models.

Clash detection

Throughout the creation of your project, you and you team have been doing “clash detection” as you go, resolving what is clearly wrong. Now we will use computational clash detection to make sure there are no conflicts of constructibility. There are 3 types of clashes encountered in clash detection:

  1. Hard clashes: Geometric, direct clashes AKA probably what you think of when you think of a clash. HVAC intersecting a structural beam is an example.
  1. Soft clashes: the space required around an object. Examples: nothing in the way of a door opening,certain space around an operation table.
  1. Logistic / temporary clashes: Clashes related to construction itself. Ex: scaffolding blocking an access door.

3 main types of clashes

When quality control is done right

Digital technology can have a significant impact on the quality of construction when done correctly. The key is to work with your project deliverables, define the rules, and establish regular quality control checks. When you combine strong quality control with the power of computational clash detection, you are truly leveraging the power of BIM.

Carl Veillette

Co-founder and Chief Product Officer

You might be interested in:

May 7, 2018 4 min. read

What’s the first thing that pops into your head when you think issue tracking software? Clashes? And probably: “But I handle them all in Navisworks, it’s fine.” Have you ever noticed when someone says they are fine, they usually mean the complete opposite?

July 28, 2016 4 min. read

In the world of BIM, clash detection is the terminology used for automating collision finding prior to construction issues in the field during design and preconstruction.

July 31, 2017 2 min. read

What if you could access and leverage the design team’s or sub’s building information models for construction coordination, estimating, and scheduling more easily?